Archives for:

The “Sting” and Context of Libel

In a recent defamation decision, Baglow v. Smith, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice emphasized the importance of the context in which alleged defamatory statements are made. The plaintiff, Baglow, and the defendant, Smith, operated internet blog sites which served as venues for political commentary for guest bloggers. They were engaged in a heated debate […]

Bordonaro c. Voyages David Inc. et Alitalia Airlines: Liability for Delay under the Montreal Convention

In a Quebec Small Claims Court decision, Bordonaro c. Voyages David Inc. et Alitalia Airlines, it was ruled that an airline was not liable to passengers for an over three hour flight delay.  The plaintiff purchased tickets for his children who were to fly from Bari to Rome and then from Rome to Montreal.  The […]

Richards v. Air India Ltd.: Travel Agents and Letters of Credit

Ceylinco Investments Ltd, operating as Chalais Travel and Tours, was an authorized passenger sales agent of Air India. As an IATA accredited agent, it did not directly pay the airlines for the tickets it sold, but instead used the IATA Bank Settlement Plan (BSP).  This payment method was based on the agent reporting ticket sales […]

City Held Liable for the presence of a hill in a Park

The Alberta Court of Appeal in Christensen v. Calgary (City), recently dismissed an appeal by the City seeking to overturn a trial decision in which the City was held liable to two in-line skaters who had been injured while attempting to skate down a pathway on a hill within a city park. At trial, the […]

Jurisdiction under Warsaw Convention: Ontario Superior Court of Justice stays an action arising out of the international carriage by air

In a recent decision, Ashad v. Deutsche Lufthansa Aktiengesllschaft, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice allowed the airline’s motion to stay the passenger’s action on the grounds that Ontario Courts did not have jurisdiction under the Warsaw Convention. The plaintiff passenger alleged that he suffered personal injuries when he unintentionally swallowed pieces of shredded glass […]

The Ruling on Costs in Giuliani v. Region of Halton

In Giuliani v. Region of Halton, 2011 ONSC 5119 (CanLII) the Honourable Justice John Murray of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, recently delivered his reasons on costs of the action, in which the Plaintiff was awarded damages of $375,000 at trial, yet claimed in excess of $550,000 for legal fees on a substantial indemnity basis, […]